In question 9 Leaving Cert Higher Maths Paper 2017. Students were asked to insert scaled axes on a given diagram .The marking scheme gives 10 marks (out of 20) for drawing a vertical or horizontal axis (unscaled) or 18 marks for fully scaled vertical or horizontal axis. So why are the marks so generous?. Reason **the question cannot be done !** The information in the question is conflicting and incorrect.

We are given f(t) = a+bCosct and told that f(2)=5.5 and f(14.56) = 5.5, but using information in the question we get f(0) =5.5 ,f(2) = f(14.56) = 4.6 .It is therefore impossible to label and scale the axes .**Any student who attempted the question should receive full marks (20).**

## Leave a Reply